Subtitles?

[metiu]

Hi

I've got big proublem with BSPlayer. I've updated last build (808) with new one (809) and from that moment subtitles are not showing when I play a movie. It's strange but it's true What can I say: I've got all new codecs and I've tried diffrent way (uninstall BSPlayer + delete the folder than install new version)... I've noticed that happens when I open movie with subtitles type 00:00:00 (h:m:s) I don't know if this bug happens in other type's of subtitles...

lastly sorry for my english I'm still learning


Metiu

[netzah]

I can confirm that. Subtitles are not shown by .809 on my system. I've got Win2000 SP4 (PL), GeForce 2MX with 29.42 detonators, K-Lite Codec Pack 2.27.
My friend has the same problem, he uses WinXP & RivaTNT, don't other details.

[metiu]

Originally Posted by netzah

I can confirm that. Subtitles are not shown by .809 on my system. I've got Win2000 SP4 (PL), GeForce 2MX with 29.42 detonators, K-Lite Codec Pack 2.27.
My friend has the same problem, he uses WinXP & RivaTNT, don't other details.

I've got: WinXP, GeForce 4Ti 4200 with 56.72 detonators...
btw. are you from Poland? :)

Metiu

[netzah]

That's right, i'm from Poland 8)

[netzah]

Update:
It's not drivers/codes/hardware related. It's subtitle format.

working:
{3668}{3694} txt
{3820}{3937} txt
{3937}{4011} txt

not working:
00:02:27: txt
00:02:44: txt
00:02:47: txt

[metiu]

Originally Posted by netzah

Update:
It's not drivers/codes/hardware related. It's subtitle format.

working:
{3668}{3694} txt
{3820}{3937} txt
{3937}{4011} txt

not working:
00:02:27: txt
00:02:44: txt
00:02:47: txt

Just as I suspect... When build .810 will be ready?

[gircobain]

Originally Posted by netzah

not working:
00:02:27: txt
00:02:44: txt
00:02:47: txt

And what subtitle format would that be?
I mean, you don't expect BSPlayer to support some weird subtitle format someone decided to come up with, do you?

[netzah]

Originally Posted by gircobain

And what subtitle format would that be?
I mean, you don't expect BSPlayer to support some weird subtitle format someone decided to come up with, do you?

I don't know what format would it be, but it was supported by all builds up to 808 and now it's not. So i don't expect BSPlayer to support weird formats, i expect BSPlayer not to remove support for present ones.

[adicoto]

This format is among the most common uncommons. :D . But it was supported. If you don't have the suntitle on a cd, try to convertit using subadjust. Sometimes it makes wonders.

[netzah]

But why the support was removed? :roll:

[adicoto]

Good question.

[pozmu]

It's TMPlayer format, widely used in Poland.
Was removing support for this subtitle format intentionally? If yes... please, tell us why did you do this? If no, please make some type of fix/ patch/ new release.... 809 version support automatic line breaking, which is very improtant for me, but it's useless becouse I can't use my subtitles (most of them are in TMPlayer format)

Thanks

[adicoto]

Probably BST have something in mind. Let's hope all will be solved. Meanwhile, as I posted earlier, if the subtitle is not on cd try to change the format.

[pozmu]

Yes, of course I can convert the subtitles, but it's not a solution (but even you can have subtitles on cd, you can copy converted version to hdd, so this is not a problem).

[zrk2002]

If the problem with tmplayer format subtitles will not be solved in next version of bsplayer I propose to change the name of bsplayer. New name should be : nbsplayer (NOT BEST PLAYER)
rgs.
zrk2002 :!:

[adicoto]

Sorry to say that, but sooner or later, that format will not be supported probably any more. Srt, sub, ssa for text based subtitles are leading the market and are supported even by hardware DivX players.

[robertjdb]

Even though txt files are not the most widely supported formats, I is still annoying that as from 809 BSplayer does not support the subtitle format with time stamps instead of frames anymore.

I have masses of CD's with this format and for me that means that if it is not included in 810, I will stick with 808 or find another player.

It is the most widely used format in Poland and here in The Netherlands it is also very widely used.

It is very easy to change an error in such a subtitle with even a simple application like notepad.

[BSPeter]

Originally Posted by robertjdb

annoying that as from 809 BSplayer does not support the subtitle format with time stamps instead of frames anymore.
...............It is very easy to change an error in such a subtitle with even a simple application like notepad.

I would say textbased .srt (SubRip) subtitles represent the overwhelming majority in the Netherlands. Contrary to what you suggest, they are fully supported by BSPlayer. They can be edited easily in e.g. Notepad and surely are based on time: e.g.

1
00:00:25,729 --> 00:00:28,688
Ze zeggen dat Japan gemaakt
is door een zwaard.

2
00:00:31,407 --> 00:00:35,056
Ze zeggen dat de oude goden het
koude staal onderdompelden in de oceaan.

[metiu]

Originally Posted by robertjdb

I have masses of CD's with this format and for me that means that if it is not included in 810, I will stick with 808 or find another player.

Exactly - I've got many movies with this format... Maybe Srt, sub, ssa formats are leading the market but BSPlayer Team must think about this little countries such as Poland otherwise BSPlayer won't be the best movie player ever created :( I believe that build 810 will fix that bug!

[bst]

Could you please attach subtitle that don't work here ?
Also file name of movie and subtitle.
Support for this format was not removed.
Only change is that if there is a lot of files in directory player doesn't try to auto load subtitles, because it's very hard to know which subtitle is for which movie and usually have different name than movie.