So you want this (picture at the right):
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/64aa1/64aa1329d9f76a5977779465fff9631d260839a7" alt=""
First select 4:3 as default aspect ratio under
(rightclick > ) Options > Preferences > Playlist
Further deselect "Keep aspect ratio" under
(rightclick > ) Video.
Then follow
adicoto's advice or (alternatively)
(rightclick >) Video > Aspect ratio ... select 4:3.