Frequently asked questions - BS.Player wiki problem with the encoding of subtitles
Further: Is "Use new subtitle parser/renderer" (under [Subtitle properties]) selected or not?
Try if changing that setting does make a difference.
Perhaps verify the actual script used for the subtitles while the movie is running
(rightclick > Subtitles > Primary > Subtitle properties > Font ...)

@
adicoto: your search-link doesn't work